The ultimate guide to VDI
i. What is VDI?
VDI, or 'Virtual Desktop Infrastructure' is a software delivery technology that presents end-users with a virtual desktop, running on a centralized server, from which to launch software titles. Also referred to as 'Desktop Virtualization', it has a number of facets which have resulted in its being heralded as the technology of the future when it comes to software delivery. The delivery method to end all delivery methods. Whilst, it is an impressively powerful piece of technology that is technically capable of delivering any application to any device in the correct circumstances, its associated costs prevent it from being a total solution and tend to render it inviable for use for any contexts other than where it is necessary.
ii. A short history of VDI
The term 'VDI' or Virtual Desktop Infrastructure was coined by VMware and the technology holds several years of development history prior to being officially named and adopted by major players in the software delivery market. With highly organic roots and genuine demand from the market, VDI began as something of a workaround-improvement upon server virtualization.
iii. How does VDI work?
VDI works in very much the same way as server virtualization which, in TechTarget's words 'is a process that creates and abstracts multiple virtual instances on a single server'. Used for partitioning and creating multiple environments on a single server, each of which carries the ability to run discreetly and independently. With these capabilities, it is easy to see how server virtualization spawned VDI in its embryonic stage, and why VDI was subsequently developed and built upon the foundation of server virtualization. A simplified overview of how VDI works is as follows:
The end-user requests a desktop through their hardware, be it a fat client or a thin client (VDI is can be delivered to both without further components or software, given that all processes are executed on a server in the data center, rather than on the end user's hardware. Their request is managed through a connection broker to validate the requesting user's credentials and consult a license repository for available VDI licenses and OS licenses. Following successful validation, and providing licenses are available, virtual machines, complete with the relevant operating system, are 'spun up' on partitioned servers in a data center. The operating system, in this case, is synonymous with the 'desktop', which is then delivered via a network connection to the end-user and their hardware.
Desktop-based, server-based and session-based VDI
According to Parallels, there are three methodologies of delivering virtualized desktops, those being desktop-based VDI, server-based VDI and session-based VDI. Each of these methodologies lends themselves to either persistent or non-persistent VDI, which you can read more about in the next section of this guide. As for the differences between Desktop, server and session-based VDI, they are defined by Parallels as:
- Desktop-Based VDI
A desktop running in a virtual machine that is hosted on a server in the datacenter.
- Server-Based VDI
A desktop running in a server operating system that is available only for a single user at a time (Remote PC).
- Session-Based VDI
An individual session running inside a server OS on either a virtual machine or a physical server.
Based upon these descriptions it can be surmised that desktop-based VDI forms the basis for most contemporary VDI solutions, server-based VDI is slightly closer in function to its origin, server virtualization, and that session-based VDI is something of a hybrid, calling upon principles from both desktop and server-based VDI.
Persistent VDI Vs Non-Persistent VDI
As described in SearchVirtualDesktop's article, 'Understanding nonpersistent vs. persistent VDI', the difference between the two types of VDI boils down to whether a desktop can be accessed by one user at a time, or many users simultaneously.
With persistent VDI, each user gets his or her own desktop, also known as a one-to-one ratio. Nonpersistent desktops are many-to-one, meaning that they are shared among end-users.
'Understanding nonpersistent vs. persistent VDI', Alyssa Provazza, SearchVirtualDesktop, April 18th 2018
It is difficult to argue with the claim that accessing a persistent VDI desktop provides a better user experience, given that this option imbues the user with the ability to customize their data, settings, shortcuts, etc. As implied by the title, this desktop and its settings will persist and remain the same each time it is accessed on a user-by-user basis until that user makes further changes to their desktop. User data is stored on the virtualized desktop and file storage is written to and managed on a separate drive. Given that constant settings and preferences rely upon a one-to-one ratio of virtual machines, more storage, and more VDI licenses are required, incurring higher costs across the board. It is also worth noting that VDI desktops must still be imaged, and that imaging for persistent VDI retains all the challenges of traditional imaging.
Built from a master image, or golden image, non-persistent VDI is naturally much simpler and less time-consuming from an imaging perspective; due to the nature of imaging, regardless of the size, one large image is an awful lot more manageable than multiple smaller ones. This facet, along with the fact that non-persistent VDI desktops can be shared by multiple users, means that non-persistent VDI is less time-and-cost-consuming to manage and requires less storage to operate that its persistent counterpart. An added benefit is that, should security be compromised via hacks, desktops can be rebooted using the single, master image.
To summarize very generally, persistent VDI provides a more comprehensive solution for end-users, with a better and richer experience. Universities with the goal of improving the student experience through technology for better retention and improved grades should consider persistent VDI. In contrast, non-persistent VDI is a still-powerful solution that provides very versatile access to software, with a more stripped-back experience for end-users, but is much less complex, time-consuming and resource-demanding to implement and maintain. Universities seeking a more refined process for IT in delivering software, including reduced support tickets, a safer environment, and a generally lower cost should consider non-persistent VDI.
iv. How does VDI compare to other technologies?
How does VDI compare to application virtualization?
VDI doesn't have end hardware requirements
With application virtualization, it is not possible to access and run software titles from a thin client without first adding more servers and virtualized operating systems between the server on which apps are virtualized and the end-device. VDI features these 'extra' components out-of-box and allows users to access and run applications regardless of the hardware capabilities of the device they're using. This is due to the fact that all operating system and application processes are executed on the virtualizing server and are then pixel-streamed to the end device. A drawback of this is that VDI may demand more from your servers.
"VDI requires more bandwidth and server horsepower for larger displays & multiple monitors. Users who normally work like this might have a worse experience through VDI."
Brian Madden, VMware blog
VDI can deliver cross-platform
Virtual machines are spun up and deployed from servers in the data center and then pixel streamed to the end user's device, rather than actually executed on that device. As mentioned above, this facet truly is one of VDI's greatest strengths and assets. This feature also results in cross-platform delivery being enabled, given the information streamed to the end device is purely output data, such as audio and visual information. Imagine being able to deliver SolidWorks to a Chromebook, or AutoCad to an Android tablet with a keyboard and mouse connected...
VDI can deliver off-site
If licenses dictate a software title may only be used onsite, then access for students becomes limited and stifles the ability for remote working. Once again, for the reason stated above, VDI solves this as the application is technically being run onsite, with only the user input and data output occurring on the end device.
VDI has enterprise-grade security
Virtualizing onsite also results in improved security. Through connection brokers, VPN and PCoIP, connection requests are able to be handled, verified and validated with little-to-no opportunity for bypass or circumvention. This means that all sensitive data stays onsite in managed servers and access is reliably policed to dispel hacking, disruption of service, etc.
VDI is more demanding
VDI is a hugely powerful solution, as evidenced by the previous points. As expected, a solution with the potential of VDi comes at a cost, in terms of monetary investment, time to implement/manage and staff resources required to do so. Whilst desktop virtualization is expensive in itself, the costs really start to mount up when additional Microsoft licenses, the salaries of specialist staff, and the amount fo their time required are factored in. Application virtualization just does not require as many hands on deck to implement. It is also a simpler process with fewer steps that is much easier to learn and become proficient in than VDI.
How does VDI compare to imaging?
Aside from the context of security, in which imaging as secure as VDI, all of the comparisons between VDI and application virtualization ring true for imaging. VDI can deliver offsite, cross-platform and does not rely upon end hardware capabilities, whereas imaging can only deliver to Windows, onsite and requires end hardware that matches the requirements of each respective software title. The cost comparison also holds true for VDI vs imaging.
VDI can deliver to managed and non-managed machines
Imaging is a tried and trusted method of delivering software to managed machines. Whilst it is time-consuming, it is a vast improvement upon traditional installation; imagine manually installing every software title on each machine individually! That being said, imaging falls short in that there is no way to leverage it to deliver software to non-managed machines (technically, there is, but that would entail IT going hands-on with non-managed machines and deploying images to them one-by-one. Alongside the support requests this would generate, it is just not a viable method of delivering software.). As previously established, VDI is capable of delivering to non-managed machines regardless of their location, end-hardware, etc. It is worth noting, however, that VDI desktops themselves are often imaged with a 'golden image'.
VDI images are more flexible than traditional images
Virtualized desktops must still be imaged for software titles to be available to end-users on their VDI desktop, whether persistent or non-persistent. The common practice in provisioning for VDI is to deploy a number of different golden images to groups of virtual machines and assigning them to relevant labs. Whilst still using imaging, imaging for virtualized desktops is a much simpler and more flexible task, given the machines aren't physical, alongside a number of other facets.
i. What are the benefits of using VDI?
Deliver cross-platform with VDI
With its ability to spin up a virtual machine complete with an operating system, and deploy it to a dedicated client or HTML5 browser, VDI is capable of delivering applications cross-platform, be it Windows apps to MacOS, or delivery to lesser-used and supported operating systems such as Linux. An interesting example use-case from a AppsAnywhere customer was a dentistry faculty needing to deliver to tablets for efficient, ergonomic and hygenic use of machines in a dental practice environment.
VDI doesn't rely upon end hardware
As above, due to VDI spinning up and virtualizing machines server-side, execution is all taken care of away from the end-device, with visual/audio output streamed down to the end-user's device and input being streamed up to the server. This means that server hardware is used instead of end-device hardware and allows software titles whose hardware requirements would far exceed the hardware of the end machine to be run. The payoff for this is that VDI requires a strong and constant network connection.
VDI is more secure
VDI benefits from greater security due to all of the important stuff being handled onsite. Will the bulk of computing being executed on secure university servers in a data center, VDI provides a more robust and safe way of delivering applications to devices and users in nonsecure locations or on unsecured networks. File storage also occurs server-side which means that more traditional security risks, such as theft of a machine, do not result in data loss.
VDI is more license compliant
Many software titles' licenses stipulate that they may only be run onsite. This would kill any true BYOD strategies before they had a chance. The same goes for plans to deliver to satellite campus'. Once again, due to VDI's facet of processing and executing away from the end machine, it is a perfect solution for getting around tricky license requirements to deliver a great experience to students and users wherever they are. Essentially, the app is still being run onsite, but the user is able to input and see the output remotely.
ii. What are the limitations of VDI?
VDI is the most expensive method of delivering software
Not only does VDI carry the highest price tag in general, but the resources it demands drive costs up even further. Capable server hardware, extensive storage requirements, a team of specialists, VDI licenses themselves, etc etc etc. VDI may even necessitate a stronger and more capable network signal than is currently present!
It's very complex to implement and time-consuming to manage
A solution built upon an already-complex technology, developed by a multi-company team of the brightest minds in software delivery tech and driven by a real market need to solve a very sophisticated problem... It is easy to see why desktop virtualization is so resource-hungry and complex! There are multiple components to set up and manage, such as connection brokers, VDI servers and storage drives, all of which must interact with software license servers whilst communicating properly with VPNs and firewalls. And that is a massively oversimplified description of what's actually happening under the hood. However, even without fully delving into the intricacies of VDI, it makes perfect sense that it is so demanding. A lot of complicated components are required, and the more components there are, the more 'intersections' for failure or error there is.
VDI demands a highly specialized team
It takes specialist knowledge to manage and deploy any software delivery methods, however, VDI's complexity is a level above that of traditional install, imaging or application virtualization. This is reflected in the team it requires for implementation, deployment, and management.
VDI requires a strong and constant network connection
VDI's greatest strength is also one of its greatest weaknesses. The fact that almost everything is carried out on servers in a data center means that a constant connection must be maintained between the end device and relevant servers. Not only must this connection be reliable and uninterrupted; it must also be strong. The bandwidth and speed of the network connection must comfortably exceed the requirements of both the operating system and software titles being accessed.
How much does VMware’s VDI cost?
Estimating the price of a VDI solution depends on a lot of factors; your university’s needs for the solution, the number of managed and BYO devices, infrastructure hardware, and more. The average cost to implement VDI through VMware – with discounted higher education-specific pricing – is usually in the region of $200 per student (concurrent user) per year. Over the typical 5-year period of any VDI investment, that equates to $1,000 per user.
This pricing includes hardware, which all schools will need for any VDI deployment*, VMware software licenses, and annual maintenance on all components. This average cost does not include the high-value salary cost of a specialist VDI administrator.
*unless a cloud-based VDI deployment, which would incur higher costs in the form of hosting charges etc.
This average pricing for VMware in Higher Education is for on-campus managed devices only. If you need to deliver to student devices and enable BYOD access, the costs will increase due to the need for an additional ‘VDA’ (Virtual Desktop Access) license from Microsoft. Another downside to this approach is that your performance is typically ‘locked-in’ for the duration of the term (5 years). That means it’s more difficult to take advantage of the latest performance, features and technical developments that are available.
ii. Product Spotlight: Parallels RAS
Some useful & related reading..
AppsAnywhere's integrations with Parallels RAS empowers higher education IT to delivery Windows applications to non-Windows devices; learn more in our webinar, delivered by Phil Spitze.
Michigan's Calvin University, founded 1876, are leveraging BYOD to reduce cost and complexity of traditional VDI, all thanks to AppsAnywhere
Read our case study on how Highline College has consolidated its VDI tools, reduced the number of images in their software delivery estate and provided more software access options for their students.
i. Who to ask about VDI?
VDI is a specialist industry and so it can be difficult to locate reliable learning resources and comparison tools. Alongside the rest of this guide, this section will detail some valuable resources and key figures to refer to in your pursuit of knowledge in the field of VDI!
Ruben Spruijt is Sr. Technologist at Nutanix, former CTO at Frame and a well-regarded author, speaker, market analyst, technologist; Truly an all-around End User Computing geek. He is an authority on virtualization and has published books/e-books on varying aspects of the field, including 'The Ultimate Desktop Virtualization Best Practises Guide' (download) and 'VDI Smackdown'. Ruben also is a Microsoft Most Valuable Professional (MVP), NVIDIA GRID Community Advisor and was in the Citrix CTP program from 2008-2017 and VMware vExpert from 2008-2018.
Ruben (co)founded several independent industry bodies such as Project Virtual Reality Check (VRC), VDI Like A Pro, Team Remote Graphics Experts (TeamRGE), WhatMatrix, AppVirtGURU wrote and co-authoring multiple disruptive research papers. Ruben has presented more than 450 sessions at national and international events such as BriForum, Citrix iForum Japan, Citrix Synergy, Gartner Catalyst, Microsoft Ignite, Microsoft TechEd, NVIDIA GTC, and VMworld.
He is based in the Netherlands where he lives with his wife and three kids.
Rory is the founder of rorymon.com, the host of 5 bytes Podcast and has worked with numerous organizations to help them implement virtualization services as well as with various technology providers to develop their products and add further integrations, such as Citrix XenApp's App-V integration. He is widely considered to be a key influencer in the field of application virtualization specifically and his Twitter account is a fantastic source of the latest industry news, releases, and developments.
From December 2014 he began contributing to Ruben Spruijt's Application Virtualization Smackdown ver. 4.1. He has since worked on its newest iteration, a digital matrix, and has been recognized as a Citrix CTA, VMware vExpert, Unidesk Certified Engineer, and a Microsoft Certification Technology Specialist. Rory is also a site owner of AppVirtGuru.com alongside Ruben.
ii. Where to learn about VDI?
Once again, with application virtualization being such a niche topic, there is not an awful lot of material to learn from in comparison with other areas of IT/technology. As before, however, this works to our benefit and results in there being little-to-no misinformation spread on a mainstream scale and in the materials that do exist being authoritative and of very high quality. Read more about those resources below.
'VDI Like a Pro' was, and still is, focused on executing tests, finding insights, deep technical best practices and performance analysis in the server hosted desktop industry. The results are reported in multiple whitepapers that (after registration) were made free to download for everyone.
The goal of VDI Like a Pro is to analyze the developments in EUC, specifically the application and desktop virtualization market, and to objectively present the results. In the haze of the extreme rate of innovation within the virtualization market and corresponding marketing promises, this information is highly appreciated. Therefore, we will publish our methods and conclusions in various whitepapers which can be downloaded from our website.
Ultimate Desktop Virtualization Best Practices Guide
Sponsored by Atlantic Computing and Intel Corporation and featuring contributions by Erik Bohnhorst, Magnar Johnsen, Helge Klein, Rory Monaghan, Nick Rintalan, Ruben Spruijt, and many more. The Ultimate Desktop Virtualization Best Practices Guide is formatted as a 'Tweet-storm' and is THE definitive and most prolific source of insider tips and tricks for implementing and managing a desktop virtualization estate.
WhatMatrix: Virtualization comparison
WhatMatrix's comparison tool for general virtualization solutions includes, but is not limited to, VDI products. This tool is a great place to compare solutions broadly, and to identify to facets and features of different types of virtualization, such as desktop virtualization versus server virtualization. Using this tool you can compare products from major virtualization providers such as Citrix, VMware, Parallels, and Nutanix.
WhatMatrix: DaaS comparison
Similar to WhatMatrix's Virtualization Matrix, this comparison matrix focuses on hosted desktop virtualization, also known as Desktop as a Service (DaaS). With a more specific view of virtualization solutions, this tool is ideal for comparing DaaS vendors and their products, such as Citrix, VMware, CloudJumper and Nutanix.
Some useful & related reading..
There are many ways you might deliver your software estate to end-users. But with each one having a different pricing model, it's worth knowing the additional costs involved in Microsoft licenses.
One of the unique challenges in managing computing in a university is how to deliver apps to students in a cost-effective manner, while ensuring a good user experience...
Learn how university IT can deliver any app to any device (including Chromebooks) thanks to AppsAnywhere's integration with Parallels RAS, at a fraction of the cost of traditional VDI solutions.
From Smart Prioritization to in-depth Analytics data, learn more about the features and benefits of our application delivery solution, AppsAnywhere.
Make informed strategic IT decisions by understanding how students are consuming academic applications, including how, where and when.
AppsAnywhere integrates with the software deployment and EdTech tools you already use, including SCCM, VDI, App-V, Jamf, Microsoft and Canvas.